I got a computer around 2000 and spent a couple years with Sibelius. That's all I did. I was having a blast working on a piano trio. My father liked a lot of what I had but I have no chops on piano especially the left hand so I gave up on it.
Now I'm using Musescore.
The piano roll in digital audio workstations has become a common way to write music. FL Studio has the best piano roll by far.
It doesn't suit me even though I've done it a lot. I don't like to use a midi keyboard to write. I just use a guitar and put a rough idea down in Musescore.
+ Reply to Thread
Posts 51 to 82 of 82
12-08-2017, 03:56 AM #51
12-08-2017 03:56 AM # ADS
- Join Date
12-11-2017, 12:23 AM #52
Hey Joe... haven't read the whole thread yet. I imagine most if not all of my initial thoughts have already been shared, as well as other great ones... but good starting points I find to be
- Write a contrafact... just take a tune you know and compose something new
- Re-harmonize... take a tune and change the chord progression. I think this can actually be exceptionally difficult, especially if you already know the tune. Maybe open the book to a tune you aren't familiar with, try and cover up the chords so you don't see them, jot down the melody, and then find a chord progression you like that works
-Similar to that, take a tune and get rid of the key signature... or simply change it, so that the melody morphs into something else altogether. Then once all the intervals are off and the melody sits within the key in a different way, try and write a chord progression that fits.
(Example: if you change the key of Stella to C major, instead of opening with the melody Bb - A, it would just be B - A....G - A - B - F..... whole new situation now)
-Take a tune you dig and write a countermelody.... almost as though you were writing for an ensemble with 2 horns. So sometimes you might double the melody, sometimes you might have harmonized notes with it, sometimes you might be filling in the empty gaps within the melody, etc.
-Come up with a catchy rhythm... now try assigning notes to that rhythm until you find something with a personality
-I'm also just a fan of arranging a standard. There's a ton of overlap between composing and arranging. Working on our arranging skills can do tremendous things for our own compositions. Take a standard and arrange it for a group. I know you play with a group, right? So use that instrumentation. Compose a bass line maybe. Have the guitar or the left hand of the piano double it. Or maybe put the melody to the bridge in the bass and create some nice blanket harmonies with the horns to accompany the bass melody. Rephrase the melody with specific rhythms and articulations. Write a countermelody for one of the melodic instruments to play behind the lead melody. Write background hits to play for the group behind the soloist during his last chorus. There so much stuff we can do as far as arranging goes that will not only give us a great piece to play with our ensemble, but that really will rub off on our compositions... and our improvisation too frankly.
Looking forward to hearing what you come up with!NYC Jazz Guitar Masterclasses - Free Weekly Lessons
"Jordan Klemons is a great guitarist with unlimited potential. His prodigious technique is never an end in itself but instead the means to musical expression. He is a musician who looks to the past for inspiration and influence yet has a modern conception; he is someone to look out and listen for!"
12-11-2017, 09:47 AM #53
Actually I do the rhythm thing a lot - rhythm then notes.
12-11-2017, 04:50 PM #54
- Join Date
- Nov 2009
Oh, I just remembered something real important. It's not obvious when starting up so here. The overthinking. Sometimes when trying and trying and replacing stuff, and nothing seems to work.. it just might be the result of overthinking, making something more interesting just because.. What I mean is when a piece has one solid idea going for it, it's already a good one and very often all the idea (and the piece in general) needs, is support... and not additional quirks - even if those may sound nice in their own way. Imo, thats the hardest part of composing - when to know if it's time to enhance/support one idea or create another.
Well, thats just my amateur opinion. Never took a lesson .
01-02-2018, 06:50 AM #55
I have a few methods of composing (even though I always equated composing as something that you do with a pen and paper, basically writing out what you hear in your head. For me the "Writing tunes" is a more appropriate description.)
- Noodle with the guitar, find something chord/melody/"riff" that sticks and go from there, where either the fingers (subconscious) or the brain (conscious) takes you
- Try to find notes to fit a certain mood (for me usually this comes from a imaginary "scene", like from a movie)
- Hear something in your head and transcribe that asap, before it disappears.
My musical ability is kinda limited in a sense that I can only hear one guitar and the basic rhythm in my head simultaneously, so everything else is arranging around that base. Luckily I have the gear, so I can overdub until the end of days. I've read somewhere that some musically more inclined people can hear entire orchestras clearly and pretty much just write out what they heard. That's definitely not me.
01-09-2018, 03:27 PM #56
- Join Date
- Jan 2012
I have composed a lot of music and this is how it works for me:
"sitting down to write something" doesn't work for me. My best ideas come when I'm away from the instrument. When I'm in creative mode, I quickly write or record my ideas so they don't go away. These ideas are the seeds to grow new songs.
To write interesting melodies, I mess around with the notes that would naturally occur to me so I don't get into cliche's. Change the rhythm, use wider intervals to avoid melodies that sound like licks or scales.
You can write a melody to a chord progression or the other way around, but it's often most interesting to try alternate harmonies with your melody. Usually, my best songs are a combination of both.
Tell a story or describe a mood or emotion. Every good song has a purpose, beside showing off how clever you are!
01-10-2018, 05:22 PM #57
- Join Date
- Nov 2009
"cliche" has such a bad rep but sometimes one of those jumps out that rolls over all of them. And also over the one what made the thing a "cliche".
01-10-2018, 05:47 PM #58
i would suggest learning some new theory stuff and then using it as a vehicle/exercise for composing. Say you want to work on reharmonizing something, or adding more chords, or modulating or manipulating a melody or whatever, just choose one thing and write some music with it. Doesn't really matter if its good or bad as long as you 're improving and learning things. See composing like you see practicing the guitar, just do a bit every day.
Analyzing music that you like is a thing too. See what these musicians do and write similar stuff..
Try different approaches, write on other instruments besides guitar if possible, or using just theory (no instrument). Sometimes i just sing stuff on my phone.
For me at least, i find the more technology is involved, the more complicated and not fun composing becomes. For some stuff you have to use a daw, vsts or notation programs for arranging and writing scores or lead sheets, but i still find an instrument a notebook and a pencil the easier way to work
I 've written a lot of music over the years, and it is usually on demand, meaning writing tunes so your quartet can play some original material, or putting music to a vocalists tunes, or for theatre plays and dance theatre performances. I see composition as quite a "pedestrian" thing, you just use tools to achieve a goal. It s not really about inspiration, but about knowing the music and the tools to create it, and putting in the time. Then of course like performing, some people are insanely gifted on composing, but ... not all of us can be that.. Everyone can write good music with effort, same way everyone can play good music without being a virtuoso on an instrument.
02-04-2018, 02:49 PM #59
lots of advice
honestly I dont know your background, and level of composition as it is, you state youre a beginner. I have some composition behind me (a few years of collegiate jazz composition courses as well) and the honest to goodness best way to start writing compositions isnt to compose music. It's to start by arranging tunes that already exist (again i apologize if this doesnt apply.. either way it could help another forum member). If you take a look at writing from say, duke, or thad jones, or someone like that forward there are absolutely writing techniques worth noting. Again im not trying to be patronizing, but in your op, you dont specify what approach you are trying to use, are you doing 3 part writing? five part double lead? 4 part string quartet? through composed? a little more information will help and then i can throw some resources at you that would give you writing devices that would be VERY helpful im sure. At least they were for me!
02-04-2018, 03:05 PM #60
I'm reading up on songwriting and working on songwriting (similar to composing). My take away is, do it for the sake of doing it. Quantity over quality and the quality will eventually come. Turn your internal critic off.
I think it's also good to set a session time limit, say 30 minutes. That forces you to be productive and hopefully helps with turning off the critic.B+
Frank (aka fep)
02-06-2018, 11:06 PM #61"Learn the repertoire. It’s all in the songs. If you learn 200 songs, you will have no problem improvising."
02-07-2018, 01:13 AM #62
02-23-2018, 08:02 PM #63
- Join Date
- Dec 2016
1. Grab the great american song book, pick out some tunes you like, take the changes and write your own melodies over it.
2. transcribe tunes you like, melodies/changes and find out what parts you like and why -> try and mimic the parts you like, in your own context.
3. don't sit down and look at the paper and wait for the perfect melody, or the perfect changes. Write horribly on purpose, then adapt and improve. It's better to work with something you have on paper rather than wait and wait and end up with nothing after an hour or so of just trying to write something acceptable the first go.
4. do loads of writing.
5. share it with the musicians you trust, and feel like you won't be judged by.
6. do loads of writing (again).
Hope that helps you in some way!
03-13-2018, 12:02 PM #64
- Join Date
- Oct 2008
- Central New Mexico in the bottom of the Rocky Mountain chain.
Well, I just sort of fell into this idea, When you first pick up the guitar do you usually toss off a few notes to get the fingers going? Just 4 to 6 notes, some subliminal phrase lurking in the back of your mind or under those fingers. I have put together more than a few tunes that way. This began just after I learned to play enough to want to keep learning more. Had just a few scales under my fingers.
Fair warning, they didn't sound much like jazz. But I figured that would come later as I got better at jazz chords. [still persuing those chords and haven't written many tunes lately]
Here's one very fine place to start the wheels turning. The Cycle of 5ths has a wealth of ideas for digging yourself out of a compositional hole. Most places where it's found also explain it's usage.
Rich Severson [99 cent guitar lessons.com ] has a very fine class on how to turn those first 4 notes into a very nice 8 to 12 bar line. [ not blues] I have been trying to find the class and am missing it. It's called sequencing. I just tried under that title and failed to find it. He begins the class with a short tidbit about a student who couldn't think of anything to play...... wish I could remember the class title. They cost 4.99 If you listen to jazz you will hear this idea used all the time.
The class is about how your move your short melody up the neck diatonically. It makes your lines sound more like you know what you are doing.
BIAB is a very useful tool for composing, if you have a real sounding band as your white board the ideas will flow. Jazzers borrow from each other and great composers all the time.
09-15-2018, 03:49 PM #65
- Join Date
- Sep 2018
- Orlando, FL
I plug chord changes from a jazz song into my Band in a Box. Then I change the style to something totally different. If swing, make it metal, if bossa, make it reggae. Then I sit there with my guitar as Band in a Box plays it over and over and over again. I eventually spit out a few melodies that sound really good to me.
Then I play it with my band and see how well it passes the test. If it does, then I know I have something with legs. Sometimes they tell me certain parts are weak so I have to start over again, or tweak spots.
I recommend this approach just to get started.
09-19-2018, 11:30 AM #66
- Join Date
- Aug 2012
- Brooklyn NY
the only thing I'd add is to figure out what kinds of activities on average lead to satisfying results, for you. For myself, sitting down in front of a blank page and saying "time to write a tune" rarely leads to a good tune. But, practicing certain kinds of voiceleading often gives me an idea that I can then expand on. I was listening to an interview with some famous songwriter recently (maybe springsteen?) and he said "I'm not sure where inspiration comes from, but what I do know is that when it comes, you need to be able to drop everything and follow it".
Which kinda confirms my experience that I can't manufacture inspiration on demand, but what I can do is engage in activities that are likely to lead me to being creative.
02-24-2019, 11:34 AM #67
- Join Date
- Aug 2018
- Manchester, UK
Record your ideas!
Record your ideas in your voice recorder of your phone! This is what I do, and when I sit to songwrite, I have lots of ideas to build from. If you don't record them, you forget them easily.
When you record them, you are also sub-consciously saying to yourself that you value your song ideas. This makes songwriting easier in itself also.
All the best with it
02-24-2019, 05:13 PM #68
If I knew how to be a good composer, I would have a lot more money than I now have. I suspect the same applies to everyone here. I suspect that people like Hoagy Carmichael, Jerome Kern, Cole Porter, et al simply had a talent, the the talent carried them. I do not have that talent.
02-24-2019, 05:21 PM #69
Write 1,000 songs
02-24-2019, 05:55 PM #70
I have better things to do with my time than write thousands of crappy songs. Your time is your own. But my point was that I have no useful advice, and I seriously doubt that anyone else here has any either. Skilled, talented composers who write good music are pretty well known.
02-24-2019, 06:30 PM #71
02-24-2019, 06:44 PM #72
If you like tricks.
02-24-2019, 07:24 PM #73
Up at six, five hours straight, sandwich and a stroll, four more hours. You might get something worthwhile after a few months. Maybe :-)
I've never used negative harmony. I usually start with a place, or a person, a mood, a memory, or even a wise saying, and see what comes out.
But 99% of songs are about relationships. If you look at a list of standards nearly all of them reflect some kind of happening in a relationship. Reading them through a composer's eyes sheds an interesting light on them. They're not just words on a page then, they're real.
So draw on your own experience and come up with your own. If you've got any music in you something should happen. But work is the key usually.
02-24-2019, 10:19 PM #74
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
My daughter once told a little friend of hers that her daddy composed music, to which she replied, "That's impossible because people who do that are famous and you see them on TV". Ha.
I actually started making up tunes seriously around the time she was born, sitting with an unplugged solid body in the hush of the night, stealing an hour here, an hour there. I was also listening very closely to jazz at this time, which really opened up my ears, I must say. Before this time, you could say that I was a "good" rock guitarist - well, that's what people used to say.
Anyway, I have quite a lot of material right now which is awaiting finishing touches and I suppose that sooner or later it will get recorded - I posted an early attempt recently in this section. But it's difficult with work and all.
I generally agree with Ragman's words. Now, there's a man whose music often has what we call "duende" in Spanish (sort of magical quality). It doesn't matter if it's going to change the world or not - find your voice and go with it.
PS That could take a long time.
02-25-2019, 08:48 AM #75White belt
02-25-2019, 10:06 AM #76
Rag is writing tunes all the time I notice
02-25-2019, 02:49 PM #77
02-26-2019, 08:17 AM #78
If I have an idea, I try to write it down.
Sketches because tunes.
I still use a paper manuscript notebook, but became a MuseScore fan about 16 months ago. It's nice to test my ideas and hear if that's what I really was hearing....it gets better.
02-27-2019, 06:40 AM #79
- Join Date
- Jun 2018
Good stuff. If we divide the subject into a few headlines and then assign a headline to each reply, the ground is still not covered. For example;
5. Systems and Methods
6. Practice and Training
7. Tools and Technology
Most replies in this thread are about chapters 5-7, with an emphasis on 6. Practice and Training.
I think it's important to address chapters 1-4 first. Here's my take (but since this is all about art I bet there are different outlooks...)
1. Scope - A discussion about composing vs song writing, improvisation and poetry. Don't confuse lyrics with music. Lyrics could be a source of inspiration for music (or the other way around). Lyrics could be written on rhythmic meter and also be intended for someone to write music. But the areas are of separate nature. If you want to develop as a composer, concentrate on the music (If you never put words into music you may try it as an exercise). It should be possible to perform the piece without vocals. Playing with "Garage band" or similar software is not composing. Arranging samples created by someone else in sequence in a DAW is not composing.
2. Prerequisites - Instrument Skills and Music Theory.
-Is it possible to compose without instrument playing skills e.g by using technology and software? No. refer to "Scope" above.
-Could a computer compose? Not by itself. A composer would have to feed the computer with algorithms based on music theory and/or a reference base of music composed by humans. Same thing with AI -the learning algorithm is created by a human. Shit in - shit out.
-Is a sequence of sounds/noise music? No. refer to "Scope" above. The important thing to remember is that technology is not going to make better music. On the contrary there are several indicators that points in the opposite direction.
Theory (e.g Harmony, Voice leading, Counter point etc.) is of tremendous help in general.
If you learn 200 tunes/pieces/songs, playing skills will improve. Ability to improvise will improve and ability to compose will improve. (Having said that, the best instrumentalist is probably not the best composer.)
-Why do you want to compose?
-What inspires you to compose?
-What do you want to achieve?
-What is your relationship to attributes like "Catchy", "Hook", "Hit", "Improvised", "Cliche" etc?
-How is your objective connected to your motive above?
03-02-2019, 06:40 PM #80
- Join Date
- Aug 2014
I say start with arranging, feels like a natural step prior to composing to me. They had us do it during my jazz program at local uni in this order as well. Take a song you like and write it out the way you want. That helps to get the macro approach internalized
03-02-2019, 10:10 PM #81
I think writing tunes is a good place to start anyways. Songwriting... Melody, harmony, rhythm, song structure and lyrics. Just because one adds lyrics doesn't change anything, still composing. But I just like to say "writing tunes".
Just make it part of your daily or weekly routine. That will keep it percolating in your head.B+
Frank (aka fep)
04-01-2019, 03:04 PM #82
Not that I'm a great composer but I do like some of my stuff a lot.
The two best ways I get a creative streak are:
Noodling... Not practicing, not playing tunes, just letting my fingers walk.
The other is listening to tv or even a DVD while noodling. Often I'll hear 2 or 3 notes that just stop me in my tracks and I build on them and all of a sudden I take off on a tangent that makes for a completely different vibe.
Even if I only get a few bars down I record them on my phone and build as I go along.Regards,