-
Jonah -
I've often heard Tony Rice say that he didn't actually do crosspicking. At least, that's how he expressed it. Doc Watson definitely did, and said he did. Clarence White did too but, if you look at his videos, a lot of the time he's using his fingers w/pick.
What Tony Rice said he does is just kind of rolling patterns with the pick to fill out the chords instead of strumming. When you get good with a pick you just kind of do it naturally, usually combined with bass runs too.
I'm not saying, of course, that they never thought about it or practiced it. They must have done, but after a while it stops being formal and becomes part of the style. Sure, it's crosspicking in the sense you're picking across the strings but it's not a strictly formalised pattern; it's just something you do naturally when you're in the zone, as they say :-)
Trouble is, others come along, like instruction video interviewers, because players want to copy it, and ask them to break it down. So they look a bit puzzled and have to stop and think. They can't say 'Well, you just kinda do it!' so they have to do it slowly. But all they're doing really is using the pick in a flowing style. Some of it, technically, is crosspicking, some of it is sweeping, some of it might be fairly random to fit the tune.
I'll see if I can find some examples.
-
04-14-2017 09:50 PM
-
That's an interesting perspective Ragman and one I find very, well, Tony Rice. Sometimes it's easier to develop the thing without breaking it down.
You hear it often from players who have developed a certain thing that everyone is desperate to copy.
That said, this is no help at all for the generation of young Nashville session players who are expected to wheel out Tony Rice crosspicking on demand. They HAD to break it down lol.Last edited by christianm77; 04-15-2017 at 01:39 AM.
-
Hm.. I seemed to send and answer to Rag from my Samsung - but now do not see it from the computer...
Really strange...
It was too long to type it over.
I just wanted to say I totally agree.. yesterday I went through his Wildwood flower and I noticed that he does it all very freely... mixing strumming some light and strong cross picking - touching strings with his fingers... I just analyzed where the sound I lkie comes from and tried to reduce it to more regular patterns for study..
You cannot repeat such feengs lexactly.. it's like tryong to jump into a moving train by strict calculation and precise aiming.. maybbe you will manage to do it but you will look and feel stuck and awkward..
these things come whe you get natural with the technique and flow into the music feel... that is you run along the train first and just jump in
To learn from Tony's video one should use one'sar and head.. besides he seems not to know exactly what he does sometimes... I mean he is not musch of a tutor maybe... even slowing doesn fast playing sometimes seems to be a problem for him.. because this lick comes out when you play fast naturally and does not work when you do it slow...
Chris Ekdridge also plays that mix (undecipherable) way...
And Doc, Clarence and Norman Blake are much more clear...
I would say they sound often more like banjo style (like there's no sustain), and Tony implies more specific guitar features...... let it melt sound and mix
-
Breakdown being the operative word... :-)
really cool)
You know actually I do not have parobalem with these extra notes and relaxed stuff... I got into it very natureally - I just began improvizing and I felt comfortable with mixing...
Probably some recious experence helped here...
My real problem was stability, like I play on and on and suddenly I kind of get stuck ... that was actually the reason I decided to fix the basics.
And doing real cross picking... I mean satying clear in time doing cross picking without exttra notes accents strums etc. This is the roblem I have to solve now.
I want to make it now and I think that my improvized playing should improve them feel more secure...
I' ll try to do a vid of where I am now
-
Originally Posted by Jonah
-
Originally Posted by Jonah
I' ll try to do a vid of where I am now
-
Originally Posted by christianm77Originally Posted by ragman1Originally Posted by Jonah
I have a 19yr old kid who is always trying to pin me down on patterns like this. "How did you know which strings your picking? How did you learn to to put all of those notes around the melody?"
And you really just don't. You begin by strumming. Then, make it single note. Now, keep it going through the chord changes. It doesn't really matter which strings as long as it's a chord shape which works. There were no wrong notes there.
You do that enough and the instrument teaches the ears and fingers how to start doing these (initially random things) purposefully. You get to where you can play - anything which you CAN play (and that's a big qualifier)- with this filled-out style. You add lead lines and bass lines etc, but it's all just down-up. It's worth learning a some basic rolls etc., but at a certain point it's not a conscious thing.
So, you might not necessarily bear down and reverse engineer complex-intuitive. You may just work variations of random - with a soft target of things like melody, lead line, or bass. Your ears/fingers then learn, by default, to make these patterns purposeful - and you can actually articulate it the way you hear it -without really thinking.Last edited by matt.guitarteacher; 04-15-2017 at 07:50 AM.
-
I think that in that sense crosspicking is a sort of strumming too... not technically of course but semantically. Guitar is very popular instrument and I once tried to follow how differently it is played in different countries in the level of amateur song comping. Though American type came everywhere through rock and pop some trafitional features ste still there... In Italy it is strogly influenced by chitarra batente tradition. In spain it is very special of course.... in france it reminds me a mixture of romance and fiddle... in latin america lots of histircal instrumets and techniques were preserved... son, brazilian guitar, argentine,m mecican... they all have their specific strumming thst kids do in the yards or in the streets from the very beginning...In russia as a kid i heard lots of strumming mostly so called `bards` singing poets very popular movement from 60`s... usually they used the same simple harmony based on romance, prison folk, russian folk and russian gipsy... the lyrics were more important some were really great poets..
So as a kid the first thing you learnt is these specific strumming... so when I hot American music it did not really work
-
Originally Posted by Jonah
-
I kinda just consider crosspicking as a word for finger style picking chords with a plectrum
-
Thanks guys. Trying to prescribe the set rolling patterns over melodies was tripping me up. Thinking of it as a more free flowing improvised thing is helping. Still practicing the 3 note rolls but conceptually it helps to not get married to them when working on an arrangement.
-
Originally Posted by drbhrb
Once you get some basic technique with it, it basically becomes about broader phrasing issues. Tony Rice and others aren't able to articulate those cross picking things on-the-fly only because of an ability to conceive the iterations of polymetric cross picking - relevant to upcoming melodic passages so much.
It's more that they have an infinite way of rhythmically articulating a given melody. They aren't locked in . They can adjust the phrasing to facilitate what needs to be played or vice versa.
When you listen to the cross picking passages the rhythms are always altered . That's what makes them musically interesting and cool, but it also facilitates the style . It's really synergistic win-win.
Beyond fundamental technique, the most important thing there is to be able to catch up or slow the phrase back down when it gets ahead/behind by a certain amount. Really fundamental to jazz playing in my mind as well. Maybe more important than almost anything else. I think the temptation is to infer that fantastic phrasing is simply the RESULT of great playing. Personally, I think, it's probably the thing which drives the ability to technically pull anything off.
-
How could we not mention the great Robert bowling!?
This blows my freekin mind
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Originally Posted by 55bar
-
Originally Posted by 55bar
Now... imagine all that strumming replaced (mostly) with x-picking rolls... mmm!
-
How could we not mention the great Robert bowling!?
Great struff... I really like it...
Pat Metheny could have sounded like this if he had stayed in Lee Summit for a longer while...)))
I mean this sounds a bit more modern and conventional than traditional bluegrass... sounds like kind of 'some folk guitar'
I watched hs other vids... I heard him actually in group... it sounded quite traditional.
But.. .
there's always a' but'
Not as critics.. but some specualtions
I see that he does a lot of more modern country-pop stuff - just using acoustic instrument.
On one hand it's cool... because it gives an entry for guys like me (who was not born in Deep Gap).
I mean when I listen to Tony Rice I understand that it's not even technique but just the feel tat I will never get. And when I listen to this.. well I am not sure but at least it seems like I could give it a try
On the other hand there's a risk to get blended too much completely in pop stuff...
sometimes it happens when traditional player musicians try to become more conventional and accessable...
I mean Tony or Doc soound authentically crude and it makes it very specia,so individual.. and in a way subtle...
I hadn't heard him before. He's got the 6th to D. And nice guitar.
Now... imagine all that strumming replaced (mostly) with x-picking rolls... mmm!
-
Originally Posted by Jonah
I have his album it's quite traditional.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Here's a nice little crosspicking lesson -- not everything you need to know, but plenty to work on, at least.
-
Any links to the "modern country pop stuff"
in comparison to Norman Blake, Doc, Clarence White, Tony Rice (even when Tony deliberately tries to make some new things)... to be honest even Chris Eldridge with Julian LAge sound more traditional to me.
It's not about repertoire, it's about approach, sound, phrasing...
Of course Robert has traditional records too. (Actually his was teh first bluegrass record I heard, it was very traditional).
But even what you posted sound to me more like a pop-guitar playing in some folk style... you know it's like another step forward it will be like Tony Emmanuel...
Again.. let me stress... I don't say it's bad.Last edited by Jonah; 04-15-2017 at 09:39 PM.
-
Here's a nice little crosspicking lesson -- not everything you need to know, but plenty to work on, at least.
-
Originally Posted by Jonah
-
Originally Posted by Jonah
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Now that Julian's tune (Ryland) with lyrics...
New program in trio now... new record is coming on?
-
Originally Posted by Jonah
-
Originally Posted by KirkP
Like-New Gibson ES-335's
Today, 10:47 AM in Guitar, Amps & Gizmos