-
I am self taught and while I am reasonably proficient there are vast gaps in my basic knowledge. I have been getting into the habit of practicing in every key but was interested to know when you may use and encounter the keys of B#, Cb, E#, Fb?
Are there many pieces in these keys?
Thanks!
-
04-14-2019 08:35 AM
-
Practicing in all keys... how many is that?
Think about that for a bit before watching...
-
Traditionally there are 15 major key signatures
Flat Keys
C D E F G A B C ---------- 0
F G A Bb C D E F---------- 1
Bb C D Eb F G A Bb--------2
Eb F G Ab Bb C D Eb-------3
Ab Bb C Db Eb F G Ab------4
Db Eb F Gb Ab Bb C Db-----5
Gb Ab Bb Cb Db Eb F Gb----6
Cb Db Eb Fb Gb Ab Bb Cb---7
Sharp Keys
C D E F G A B C ----------------- 0
G A B C D E F# G ----------------1
D E F# G A B C# D---------------2
A B C# D E F# G# A-------------3
E F# G# A B C# D# E-----------4
B C# D# E F# G# A# B---------5
F# G# A# B C# D# E# F#-----6
C# D# E# F# G# A# B# C#---7
C Major is neutral, no flats or sharps
B#, Cb, E#, Fb?
Cb is the only one of these that has a key signature.
The others appear as notes within the key signatures with 6 or 7 accidentals.
After 7 accidentals, there is little reason to go any further.
Cb major 7 flats is enharmonic to B major 5 sharps, guess which one is more in common use.
C# major has 7 sharps is enharmonic to Db major with 5 flats, same question
Gb major with 6 flats is enharmonic to F# major also with 6 sharps, fielder's choice.
In a modulation situation is the only time I would choose to write something in Cb or C#.
I would stick with flats if I started in a flat key, or the reverse, with sharps if I started in a sharp key.Last edited by bako; 04-14-2019 at 11:40 AM. Reason: accidental redundancy
-
ISTR a flute piece with half in Cb, half in B. I think the writer was trying to make a point. The best way to notate music is the way that's easiest to read, assuming you want people to play it.
-
Probably the French
-
French-hater! (Austin Powers riff)
-
Friends don't let friends use double-accidentals.
-
Originally Posted by Babaluma
-
Thanks for all the answers!! Very helpful
-
Look here,,,
Why is there no c flat in music? - Quora
-
When the tune is in Eb Minor / Gb, and that exists ! The most famous one being .... Take Five (not written by a French by the way )
-
Originally Posted by mhch
-
Among the answers you will find is the one that says a diatonic scale must include all seven letter note names, but only each one once. That may explain why certain seemingly "artificial" accidentals are used - to enforce that the scales do include one of each letter. What is usually not explained is why and how the whole system of only seven letter named notes and accidentals, and key signatures, etc. exists in the first place.
It begins with the unexpected proper definition of the term "note". Even musicians will casually use the word "note" in the same way as the word "pitch", but this is strictly incorrect. A "note" means only one thing - a position among the lines and spaces of the staff. A particular note takes the letter name of that line or space in the staff, so the bottom line of the G-clef is called "E", and a note positioned there is an "E". That note may indicate to play different pitches based on the application of accidentals, so that E might be an Eb, or E, or even E# or Ebb... so "notes" represent multiple pitches, and which pitch you play for a note is indicated by presence or absence of any accidentals either in the key signature or temporarily applied within a measure, or a naturalization of a note subject to an accidental in the key signature or within the measure.
The reason this approach was adopted is because if you attempt to score music by assigning a chromatic pitch to each line or space of the staff, the number of lines and spaces becomes unmanageable, but even more interesting is that when you write all the diatonic scales on that kind of staff, they all show two discontinuities (the half-steps among the whole steps) in their lines of pitches, making it difficult to read. However, by using the seven note name system and enforcing it by using key signatures, all diatonic scales in all keys progress across the staff in straight lines without discontinuities, which makes reading (and reading ahead) much easier - one just needs to know the key, indicated conveniently at the beginning. So this is the result of a very clever kind of musical notation data compression system designed to suppresses the irregular appearance of the diatonic scale half steps for easier reading of written music.Last edited by pauln; 04-17-2019 at 10:09 AM.
-
Originally Posted by pauln
-
While we're at it, spell out a Cb dim7 chord: Cb Ebb Gbb Bbbb. No, your eyes do not deceive you, my leetle friends, that is a triple flat.
-
Originally Posted by BigDaddyLoveHandles
Cbo7 would be a common tone diminished chord to Cb major, while possible
is more likely to be referenced as Bo7 > B major
Fear not BDLH
-
Originally Posted by BigDaddyLoveHandles
When I come across a chart in Cb I down tools, walk over to the composer, smack him or her up side the head and tell them there is more where that came from.
More seriously, I have charted a piece in Db minor (for trumpet) because this great trumpet player refused to play anything in sharp keys. Meanwhile I am always playing flat keys for him. He caught my drift.
-
In years of reading all kinds of charts, I've never seen Fb Cb E# or B# in a chord name.
I have seen at least some of them as single notes, occasionally. I'd rather see the natural sign in every case.
My notation software has a setting to avoid double sharps, but I'm not sure how most notation software handles these notes. Say you're transposing something, will it allow you to spell with the maximum number of naturals?
EDIT: I had played that RB chart of Take Five, so I had seen a Cb, but not so often that I remembered it.Last edited by rpjazzguitar; 05-16-2019 at 02:21 PM.
-
Take Five for sure has Cb Major 7 as a chord name in the bridge section
-
Originally Posted by mhch
-
I missed the point you raised, thanks
-
Horn players prefer flats. Almost always.
So with Take 5 you go G flat not F# major
Now consider I am arranging for horns a tune in B. Unlikely .... but a good example is Stevie’s Sir Duke
Now there are horn parts on that - the horns will thank you for putting the concert key into Cb, so tenor and trumpet are reading in Db and the alto and baritone in Ab. As opposed to C# and G#.
I’ve always found this an issue when preparing parts on Sibelius. Even tunes in E and D, horns like charts with flats rather than sharps IME.
So jazz is mostly on the flat side obviously (well apart from gypsy jazz where the violinists moan about flats) for this reason. That’s also pretty much the only reason why Cherokee is inherently hard btw (not that it bothers guitarists.) Parker could play equally fluently in all the keys which was apparently very unusual in the early 40s.
-
B# = C
Cb = B
E# = F
Fb = E
-
Originally Posted by jazzman1021
-
Look it up.
Transcriber wanted
Today, 04:35 PM in Improvisation