-
Originally Posted by Hyppolyte Bergamotte
Last edited by jasaco; 11-20-2014 at 12:17 AM.
-
11-20-2014 12:13 AM
-
Originally Posted by Hyppolyte Bergamotte
Now you've changed the chords and I'm not sure what you're saying. (Your English is not working very well.)
I do see the relationship of B to Eb is the same as G to B; we're talking about a root move up a major 3rd - yes?
But you're regarding a maj7#11#5 as a chord you can resolve to? Was the Bmaj7 in your original example actually a Bmaj7#11#5? That does rather move the goal posts (to use an English expression...)
There's no way I can see a maj7#11#5 as a "I" chord, in any meaningful sense.
But just to clarify - in your new example, you're saying B7alt (expressed as Eb lydian augmented, yes?) resolves to... what? Ebmaj7? Gmaj7? Cmaj7??
-
Originally Posted by JonR
Exactement.
And yes I know my French is shaky, but it's not my first language, AND THAT'S THE POINT.
-
Hold on, you were talking about G7alt resolving to a Bmaj7 tonic.
Now you've changed the chords and I'm not sure what you're saying. (Your English is not working very well.)
I do see the relationship of B to Eb is the same as G to B; we're talking about a root move up a major 3rd - yes?
But you're regarding a maj7#11#5 as a chord you can resolve to? Was the Bmaj7 in your original example actually a Bmaj7#11#5? That does rather move the goal posts (to use an English expression...)
There's no way I can see a maj7#11#5 as a "I" chord, in any meaningful sense.
But just to clarify - in your new example, you're saying B7alt (expressed as Eb lydian augmented, yes?) resolves to... what? Ebmaj7? Gmaj7? Cmaj7??
I do apologize to have lost the sheet we received at this clinic with the Bill Evans impro on a standard,showing this particular harmonic progression.
For what I understood:
When beginning a bar with a I major chord, Bill Evans did from time to time the following thing:
just before the I major,he placed in the same bar an altered mode
-B7altered Ebmajor7
-C7altered E major7
-C#7 altered Fmajor7
-D7altered Gb major7
-D#7 altered G major7
E7 altered Ab major7
-F7 altered Amajor7
-F# altered Bb major7
-G7 altered Bmajor7
G#7 altered C major7
-A7 altered C#major7
-A#7 altered Dmajor7
The I maj7was considered by him,for a while , as the IIIth mode of a melodic minor scale,and he "enhanced" this chord by the seventh mode of this scale.
Ok ,Mister the professor ?Last edited by Hyppolyte Bergamotte; 11-20-2014 at 12:58 PM.
-
But the third mode of melodic minor isnt a major 7th. Im trying to figure this out
-
Is this a déjà vu, or what? Couple of posts above you asked the same question and he explained.
-
Yes, and he wrote the exact same thing. C major is not the third mode of MM
-
But the third mode of melodic minor isnt a major 7th. Im trying to figure this out
It's a Lydian augmented: Lydian,because the #11 and augmented because the #5
Let's take the C melodic minor scale
Cjazz minor
D Phrygian13
Eb Lydian augmented
F Lydian dominant
G mixolydian b6
A Locrian 9
B7 altered
You are not obliged to play all the notes of the Lydian augmented,,as you must already play(if you would play that like Bill Evands did sometimes) in the same bar a V7 altered : / B7alt Ebmaj7#11#5./
Play in the same bar,ie,a B7alt and then a Eb major triad or a Eb augmented triad: Eb+
Or you could play only in this bar a Ebmaj7#5 arpeggio:
on B7 alt you have within this arpeggio the Tonic,T,3, #9,#5 of B7 alt and the T, 3, 5+ and 7 of Ebmaj7#11#5
Last edited by Hyppolyte Bergamotte; 11-21-2014 at 06:06 AM.
Trenier 18" Magnolia 2012
Today, 06:34 PM in For Sale