I checked different versions of sheets (old realbook, new realbook, aebersold and one another).
Going from A to B part, all of them have C7 to lead to Fm. But the melody has the note Eb. Means, its either C7alt or.. Cm7 (as proposed kindly by just one of the books)
Listening to different recordings, I cant hear that C7 at all. There's usually some fill and a leading bass "lick" to Fm.
So, where does it come from? And how to treat such cases when wanting to learn a tune "right, safe and vanilla"?
Real books are roadmaps, not train tracks.
The C7 will suggest a variety of sounds that serve to set up a transition to a different 'mood' through shifting harmony. Try things out in as many ways as you can, and embrace different versions for suggesting options, but in the end, the choice you make as to what you include or what you make as your own version, that's your choice. That's why it's jazz. You make what makes sense to you and then YOU say it with conviction.
Maybe this is not the advice you're looking for, but thinking this way will make the music that the listener, and you, will recognize as valid.
You hear it a lot in old school players. Build your own vocabulary. Use it. Be aware of options. Use your own filters. Play what you hear. Make music.
New Real Book has all the variants you mention at a time.
My approach to standards from so-called The Great American Songbook is to treat given chords quite freely or if I particularly like some record trying ti pick up this version.
i think also some old songs have no 'orginals' often in concern of composer's intentions and I think it is ok, these songs are realtively simple often use cliche patterns based on functional harmony which allow in turn cliche substitutions. The thing is more about to keep functions there and add or change some colours.
So to me it is the matter of taste.
And Blue Moon is as basic harmonically as can be.
Also in many cases harmonic reference of malody is enough.
One can actually reduce it to just I - I - IV - V anf it will sound ok too.
Long Ago and Far Way - to me at least within the phrase it sounds like you can play almost anything if you just keep basic functions working. It will not ruin the song
Though in But Beatiful, We'll Be Together Again or Alfie it seems like you need to keep in my mind particular chords besides what is there in melody, chords there add important identy to the song.
In many Cole Porter songs chords can be very important because his melodic solutions are very mimimalistic - he often uses one or two short repetitive motives with very small pitch range that do not really describe the harmony and the chords played behind become substantial part of the song.
To some degree it concerns many songs by Duke Ellington - I'd even say with Duke it can be important to hear how he played them to get the vibe and idea of application of harmony.
Have a listen to some different versions. Easy thing to do these days.
Blue Moon is a surprisingly hip tune.
charts wise I always like looking at a few and comparing. Have a look at this for instance, as basic as it gets Blue Moon
i tend to regard the Real Book with the same sort of attitude one may treat the geographical writings of Herodotus (it’s an important historical document but that doesn’t mean there are dudes with faces in their chests or an E7b9 chord in bar 8 out of nowhere*) but the New Real book is a pretty accurate source by and large
*nb sixth edition appears to have fixed this, and other, mistakes
Last edited by Christian Miller; 11-25-2022 at 11:33 AM.
Posted By voyage (9 replies)
Yesterday, 03:53 PM in Theory
New Forum Posts
It makes crossing strings extremely easy, as the pick has to hardly move. However you have less definition and a much rounder tone with less treble. Yet another thing to puzzle us when trying to...
You can sweep pick the last line at the 6th fret, it's a GbM7 arpeggio (preceded by the notes Eb & F on the 5th string). I played the entire four bars in the 4th to 6th fret positions, shifting as...
Hello again,
I finally completed my restoration work, not perfect, but much better than original condition!
I used a smooth brush to remove all the sticky dust on the pickups and polished...
Well, hey, surprise!
I just came here to read about something else, saw this and guess what - today I also fitted JS112s to my '66 ES125 and - exactly the same: new guitar!
I didn't move the...
I have a 1st generation Parker Fly, never tried, and never needed to turn the rod. More Non-defining info, I know, but a data point on stiff necks and boards.
Thx guys. I should be ok with my existing sounds in my brick and mortar instruments for right now - my organ, and then bass, vibes, rhodes and piano sounds on my digital piano. But I'll probably...
the 120 sounds very different from the 100 or 200. 100 and 200 are more similar. I have not a/b'd them but a friend of mine has both and says the 200 is much brighter. It's a thicker guitar too,...
2 new & excellent Jazz Comping Truefire...
Yesterday, 10:22 PM in Comping, Chords & Chord Progressions