-
I am new to this Forum and this is my first post(!)
I have been playing exclusively fingerstyle acoustic guitar since 1982. Recently, I started playing more jazz and blues (including lead lines) so I bought a new Tele and put a Charlie Christian pickup on the neck.
The Tele has 11s on it and it's got a great warm tone, but I find that the action is so low compared to what I've been accustomed to (playing with medium gauge strings on an acoustic), that it is much harder for me to play (and I chose the tele because the fat neck was the closest thing I could find to my beloved acoustic).
So my question is: should I raise the action so I have a feel similar to my acoustic, or use heavier strings, or both?
Thanks for any input you can offer.
With Flat Pick by The Colonel | Free Listening on SoundCloud
Last edited by The Colonel; 12-14-2019 at 10:53 AM.
-
12-12-2019 10:14 PM
-
Hey Colonel -- welcome!
There's a lot of support here for teles in jazz/blues, and CC pickups are certainly cool (is it a Lollar?), so gear-wise you're good (well ... what amp do you have?!).
If you know how to do your own setups, then sure, play with the action and see what you think (or take it to your trusted tech/luthier). You may or may not need to alter anything else, including the strings, so we'll see.
Of course, if it's getting a great sound you like, I'd maybe consider doing nothing and seeing if you can get used to it! [If it ain't broke, don't fix it!]
Let us know what you find!
Marc
UPDATE: Nice job with "The Christmas Song!" Great sound/playing!Last edited by marcwhy; 12-14-2019 at 10:49 AM. Reason: update
-
Originally Posted by marcwhy
To answer your questions - it is a Lollar, and my current amp is a Quilter combo (though I'm seriously considering upgrading to the Fender ML Deville).
I'm just wondering if I'm so used to playing acoustic that I need to spend a lot of time on the electric to get used to it, or if I should have opted for a hollow body that played more like an acoustic. Anyway, I heard that raising the action and using heavier strings can bridge the gap between the two guitars.
I'm hoping to post a short clip of the Tele straight into Garage Band just to show the tone from that neck pick-up.
Thanks for your thoughts.
-
Assuming things aren't buzzing from being way too low, you might try living with it a bit and seeing if you acclimate...sometimes it's nice to have guitars that feel different.
-
Electric guitars are different instruments... with different touch and response...
Low action is part of its idea (especially on teles and strats)... paticular softness and smoothness of playing
Try to get used for a while...
I had those issues as I was prmarily acoustic player... but eventually I got used to it.
Also check Tim Lerchabout tele's setup. He is also very supportive.
-
Originally Posted by Jonah
Yeah I'm well aware of Tim. His playing was the main reason I opted for a Tele when selecting an electric: I thought it would give me the best options for jazz and blues. I honestly don't use the bridge pickup very much. Hope to have a sample up soon,
The Colonel
-
Putting heavier gauge strings on a guitar often means you can lower the action, heh, although you don't have to.
I have 13s now on my Tele. There's no need to have them that heavy on a solid body guitar (unlike on a carved archtop, to drive the top), but I like the tension.
As well, if you like flatwound strings, don't be afraid to put em on a Tele.
-
I think high action and light strings (10s or 11s) make for a nice combination on an electric, it is my preferred setup. My fingerstyle 512 Taylor acoustic has actually a lot lower action than most of my electrics.
-
We need the action height at the 12 th fret 6 and 1st string. One measurement is better than 10,000 guesses and then can see based on that measurement. Get a nice metal ruler with at least marks going to 1/32 many go to 1/64. Measure from top of fret to bottom of string, measure twice to be sure. Armed with that information can go forward. You can also measure relief in the neck. That is fretting at the 1 st and 14 of 15th fret to create straight line. There should be some small amount of gap from 1st to 15th fret but not much.
Report back.
-
Originally Posted by The Colonel
John
-
Originally Posted by John A.
-
Originally Posted by The Colonel
John
-
Originally Posted by The Colonel
Caution: You're new here. One of the risks of spending time on this Forum is developing a near-fatal medical condition -- Gear Acquisition Syndrome (GAS)! ["Near-fatal" since you may lose life, limb, and/or family!] It starts with something innocent, like trying a different type of pick, and then the $0.25 pick you originally used happily for years now turns into a $45 pick (that you still may lose in the couch!). From picks, you move onto strings, straps (fine, Corinthian leather!), cables (with 100% Phoenix feather core), effects (approved by members of this Forum), amps ("upgrade" to a $3000 boutique tube), and, of course, guitars. GAS-aholics share a common sentiment: Everything will be different after that next purchase!!
You have been warned.
-
1) 2) Telecasters are wonderful guitars with broad-spectrum tonal capabilities as well as seemingly infinite variations on a theme (see The Telecaster Thread), and your new axe is quite interesting. What I did with my my own '66 Custom Telecaster was to use heavier strings, and replace the threaded steel 3-barrel bridge with intonated brass barrels from StewMac. I believe that the basic resonance is affected by the three barrels resting in pairs on the six screws resting on the steel plate with an appropriate tension. It took a good deal of trial and error to arrive at the proper blend which for me is a set of 0.011 Stay in Tunes with moderate tension and stiffness. I also had a new switch installed for more choices in pickup combinations.
3) Nice guitar you've got there. Congratulations, and play it in good health!Last edited by citizenk74; 12-13-2019 at 08:29 PM. Reason: Spelin
-
the great thing about teles...and fenders in general, is that they can be tweaked to your hearts content..not only can you adjust the saddle height to whatever action is comfortable, but you can also adjust the neck..with a shim if needed...if the overall neck to body angle is not correct...(many original fenders came from the factory with shims in the neck pocket)
using heavier strings does not really change the saddle/action height..really 2 distinct issues..tho often the extra tension from heavier strings will make the neck bow increase, so that it feels as if the action has lifted a bit..but it's really not quite the same thing!!!
ideally, you want the correct bow (thru trussrod adjustment) and the correct action height
cheers
-
Originally Posted by The Colonel
An acoustic guitar is made for strumming and making lots of sound. They work great and look nice. And they can be used for other things, but are inferior to other guitars at those other things. Generally speaking, 11's are heavy for an electric guitar but are OK.
It's not uncommon for a guitarist to get used to a classical guitar, archtop with 12s, acoustic guitar for strumming, semi-hollow with 10s or 11s for jazz or pop/rock rhythm, and an electric with slinkys for rock and blues extreme bending etc. Every single one of those has a different feel, and switching off can take some getting used to.
Enjoy the ride.
-
My acoustic is used almost exclusively for fingerpicking, FYI.
-
Originally Posted by The Colonel
-
Low action is a preference based on your personal touch. Tommy Emmanuel has low action for his fingerstyle. I would venture a guess that most jazz guitarists play with a low action to facilitate faster lines. Some really really low. An aggressive touch would make low action sound pingy.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Raise your strings, naturally
I don`t mean to underestimate you since you are able to change the pickup in your guitar...sometimes people are skilled in advanced things, but need help with simpler tasks.
Don`t forget to take tuning off strings, so you can easily screw the bridge higher.
I`m with others commenting here, try to play it as it is first. Everybody do not have to play guitar like Freddie Green you know.
-
Originally Posted by marcwhy
You are right about GAS
I awakened first i had collected 66 guitars and bass guitars. I don`t no longer feel that i must soon get that and that and...guitar, i can breath easier now.
-
Originally Posted by savofenno
Wow, that's a serious case! Congrats on your recovery!
-
Added first direct-to-Garageband effort using Lollar CC neck pick-up through Apogee Duet (no EQ, effects, nothing - just wanted opinions on the clean sound/tone). Thx.
-
So as a fingerstyle acoustic player do you pluck hard to get loud volume?
If so, that technique will need to be adjusted for playing a tele with low action.
One thing I like about playing electric is that you can play softly and let the amp do the work.
I play at a weekly acoustic jam where I have to bang the heck out of the guitar just to hear myself.
But when I play plugged in I play with a much softer touch -- which is my more natural playing style.
Your tele may be set up just fine, but if you want to raise the strings it's super easy -- a small hex wrench is all that is required.
If you decide to adjust your string height, I wouldn't try to "match" your acoustic that you are used to.
I'd just go for a very small upward adjustment and see if you like that better.
-
I have fingernails for the acoustic, so I may have to lose those to get the proper touch with the Tele. I use a pick, too.
I added to my original post my first direct-to-Garageband effort using Lollar CC neck pick-up through Apogee Duet (no EQ, effects, nothing - just wanted opinions on the clean sound/tone). It's done finger style with no pick (but with a very helpful metronome that only I could hear). Just added a few seconds with flat pick, too. Pasting them here "for good measure' (cough):
Chestnuts by The Colonel | Free Listening on SoundCloudLast edited by The Colonel; 12-14-2019 at 10:59 AM.
An interview with Henry Robinett
Yesterday, 08:49 PM in Everything Else