-
I'm trying to move away from picking every note and incorporate slides, pull offs and hammer ons.
Is there any conventional wisdom as to the accents these introduce?
In other words is it more common to pick the on beat and slur into the off beat or vice versa?Last edited by charlieparker; 09-28-2024 at 04:43 PM.
-
09-28-2024 03:51 PM
-
Originally Posted by charlieparker
Slur into the downbeat slur into the downbeat slur into the downbeat
This is obviously tricky for guitar because we can’t easily slur through a string change but I basically just trained myself to slur into *all the downbeats I can* by playing bebop heads in different positions and working those slurs out.
I would also say bebop or BH added note scales are a good way to practice this.
Upside: I love the way it sounds. I think it sounds way more bebop than picking everything, though of course there are players who sound amazing without doing this.
Downside: time can get very squirrelly at high tempos so I do a lot of working out of licks this way and working them up to high tempos. For me this is about 220 bpm right now. I feel comfortable playing up there, but find that I slur less. The consistent picking becomes an asset up there in a way that it isn’t at moderate tempos.
-
Listen to sax players, e.g. [sic] Charlie Parker.
-
me too - this is so important for guitar if you want to play be-bop.
what helped me most was Chad Lefcowitz Brown's stuff on jazz articulation - 'saxologic' has some great you tube vids on Parker phrasing too
I've been working on his enclosure and approach tone exercises for a long time and they have had the biggest impact
one has to find ways to finger which enable you to slur into the chord tones. you go:
1 - 2/3; 4/5; sharp5/6; 7/1 : dum, de-yum, de-yum, de-yum, de-yum - the enclosure exercises show you how basic chromaticism is in be-bop (if the heads and solos hadn't done that already) and they force you to learn how to slur into and around every scale degree.
Chad went into this in so much detail I think - because he had loads of classical sax students who needed to have it spelt out explicitly. but guitarists need it too - because they tend to have committed to fingerings which make musical phrasing very difficult. the 'positions' on the guitar force you to phrase badly.
best thing ever - for me
-
I wouldn't be able to play Donna Lee at 320 or Confirmation at 190 without slurs. Jimmy raney studied Bird's lines and has a good thing on you tube about phrasing bop using slurs.
Sure, he uses economy picking for triplets with notes on three consecutive strings, but that's it. He didn't fall into the Chuck Wayne method of using it for everything, which is why Raney was able to use accents more powerfully than Grasso, Bruno, Wilkins, and others who followed Chuck Wayne or Joe Sgro, Joe Lano, etc...
Farlow also came up with his own way of playing the lines of Bud, with the surprise of Bird using economic picking sparingly and also slurs. Warren Nunes was another player that used slurs to great effect.
Here's Raney demoing bop picking and phrasing:
-
Originally Posted by sgcim
Thanks
-
Originally Posted by charlieparker
-
General principles
- always sing the phrase first (more for rhythmic feel than pitches)
- finger neighbour tones on the same string as target tones
- in running 8th lines slur the usual rule from the upbeat to the downbeat (this comes from horn playing)
- most of us are naturally rubbish at upbeats, so this is a good thing to get into, as is accenting the upbeats of a line as an exercise.
- however this isn't a hard and fast rule. The sense of the phrase may demand you break this rule. It depends on where the accents in the line are.
- go with what your ears and instinct say. If you have internalised the music by singing it, you'll have a good sense of what feels right and wrong.
- Do try different combinations of slurs and picking and left hand fingerings, to see what gives the best sense of the phrase.
- Don't worry about improvising this stuff. This will come once you'll internalised this stuff from working it out on a lot of phrases.
-
Originally Posted by GuyBoden
Precautionary natural sign warranted? Or am I just a dunce?
-
Originally Posted by Christian Miller
and also I might have some alternate fingerings tabbed out for bebop heads with the slurs and stuff. I’ll have to look.
-
Originally Posted by Christian Miller
MuseScore, select Notes then press "S" key.
Edit: I've had to move the Slur manually in MuseScore. (To avoid confusion, I've deleted my posts.)
I hope this is an improvement, "Precautionary natural sign" added too. Thanks.
Last edited by GuyBoden; 10-01-2024 at 07:48 AM.
-
Okay okay ... before Christian comes for me.
I don't claim that any single one of these fingerings is the best fingering for performing the whole thing.
I also think you can probably get like ... I don't know ... 70% of the benefit from working on two positions that are next to each other. If you do that, you'll have worked out the slurs on two positions with drastically different string crossings. Fingerings that start on the same finger, but different strings, will have different string crossings, obvs, but still quite a lot of overlap. Less overlap with Donna Lee though, to be honest, because the range is pretty big.
I've done about 25 bop heads this way and work on most stuff this way and these sort of choices became second nature. I'd guess if you did two adjacent positions with maybe like four or five bop heads, you'd be in pretty good shape.
donna lee fingerings.pdf - Google Drive
-
slur triplets
-
Originally Posted by joe2758
-
yeah that is me quite a few years ago
-
I like to pick the second triplet, is nice
-
Originally Posted by GuyBoden
-
Originally Posted by pamosmusic
-
For clarity. Below shows that difference between a Slur and a Tie symbol in music notation.
From: Music Theory and Composition : Music Theory and
Composition
-
Below, I think that this Barry Harris Chromatic Scale type lick, which includes a three note slur sounds good.
(It's easier to write "Slur" underneath the stave.)
Last edited by GuyBoden; 10-01-2024 at 10:34 AM.
-
Originally Posted by GuyBoden
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Originally Posted by Christian Miller
-
Originally Posted by sgcimOriginally Posted by garybaldy
-
Originally Posted by Mick-7
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Originally Posted by GuyBoden
The Loar LH-500
Today, 10:46 AM in Guitar, Amps & Gizmos