The Jazz Guitar Chord Dictionary
  1. #1

    User Info Menu

    I got a Taylor acoustic recently. I like Taylor's because to me they sound closer to archtops than Gibson's or Martin's.*
    However the action is a bit too high. I have already confirmed that this is not a truss-rod or nut height issue.

    Normally I'd just sand down the saddle if the action of an acoustic guitar is too high. But Taylor comes with this neat bolt-on neck design. In my opinion, sanding down saddles is just a hack you do to dovetail glued-neck guitars to save on the repair costs. Saddle height (ie back-angle) is a parameter that's factored into the design of a good guitar.

    What are your opinions about changing the neck angle vs sanding down the saddle? I need to take off at least 1 mm on the bass side and a little less on the treble. Should I just shim the neck instead? The current saddle height is probably the factory setup from 10 years ago (I got it used).

    *My Gibson L-00 is a more resonant guitar and sounds warmer and more open than the Taylor but I like the more focused and slightly compressed sound of the Taylor more for jazz.

  2.  

    The Jazz Guitar Chord Dictionary
     
  3. #2

    User Info Menu

    Shim the neck no question here at all. Taylor's set up on the necks is really good when doing this and relatively easy and allows some guessing. Then if you guess wrong you can correct with a shim added or taken away.

    One interesting thing you mention that has to do with Taylor guitars. I don't mind them they are decent guitars for flattops if you like flattops, however I have found them not inspiring to play or have a decent voice. They do the job for players I am just not a fan of the sound, nothing distinctive about them.

  4. #3

    User Info Menu

    Adjust the neck angle. I don't own a Taylor but I do own a flattop made by Charles Fox that uses a similar neck mount design and correcting the high action was an easy task and one I wish I had done before I tried the lowering saddle option. Live and learn.

  5. #4

    User Info Menu

    Taylor makes a graded range of neck shims to do the exact job you're looking at. I don't know if a Taylor authorized repair shop stock them or if you have to source from the factory. Do not shave the saddle. With the proper shim in place you should easily get a low, comfortable string action. If you have to contact the factory, be sure to thank them for saving you hundreds of dollars on what would otherwise have needed a neck reset.
    Last edited by whiskey02; 12-01-2022 at 10:18 AM.

  6. #5

    User Info Menu

    Hundreds of dollars for a neck reset to take of 1 mm on the bass, less on the treble? IOW, how much would you have to lower the saddle?

    I would assume that doing this with the neck will be like adjusting action on a Ken Parker archtop: you remove or add identical amounts on the treble and bass sides...

  7. #6
    Quote Originally Posted by RJVB
    Hundreds of dollars for a neck reset to take of 1 mm on the bass, less on the treble? IOW, how much would you have to lower the saddle?
    A neck reset would be practically free on a Taylor guitar. But for guitars with a glued-on dovetail necks, it makes sense to just shave the saddle if there is enough room (I have done this for some guitars).

    When lowering the saddle is the chosen solution, in order to reduce to action by an x amount above the 12th fret, you'd need to lower the saddle by 2x.
    Last edited by Tal_175; 11-30-2022 at 04:54 PM.

  8. #7

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by Tal_175
    it makes sense to just shave the saddle if there is enough room (I have done this for some guitars).
    Aren't factory guitars always set up with too high an action when first sold (so they don't buzz all over when random potential clients starts hocking the guitar)? The OP said it was apparently never set up, so it would make sense that the saddle were too high...

  9. #8

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by whiskey02
    Taylor makes a graded range of neck shims to do the exact job you're looking at. I don't know if a Taylor authorized repair shop stock them or if you have to source from the factory. Do not shave the saddle. With the proper shim in place you should be easily get a low, comfortable string action. If you have to contact the factory, be sure to thank them for saving you hundreds of dollars on what would otherwise have needed a neck reset.
    Yup. Taylor authorized repair shops all have a box of all different shims graded for easy replacement. I used to do this easily for action/neck adjustments. Take out the one that's in there, find the next size, drop it in, bolt it back, string it up and charge what you do for a half hour's work. New strings as part of the deal. Easy peazy

  10. #9

    User Info Menu