The Jazz Guitar Chord Dictionary
Reply to Thread Bookmark Thread
Page 3 of 8 FirstFirst 12345 ... LastLast
Posts 51 to 75 of 199
  1. #51

    User Info Menu

    here's another clip of the HORRIBLE gibson 175. Someone posted this on jazz guitar addiction. This is a student at eastman.

    performed by Greg Chako. I'm sure it'll be chastised by the tragically hip among us. So post an example of how much better your axe sounds.


  2.  

    The Jazz Guitar Chord Dictionary
     
  3. #52

    User Info Menu


  4. #53

    User Info Menu


  5. #54

    User Info Menu

    I like orginal es-175.

  6. #55

    User Info Menu

    Rio. Had a similar problem to you-but slightly different . I had an orange label Gibson 175 back in the late 80's which I really liked but due to other circumtances had to sell it. Had several others plus copies but none lived up to the original. About two years ago I tried several Tokai FA 70( 175 copy) and found one that was the nearest to the Gibson 175- price £500 Gibson used circa 1975 £ 2500.No brainer for me. I think you can still get obtain the Tokai .Try it you may like it,

  7. #56

    User Info Menu

    Buy something inexpensive. You'll also need to think about amplification as these are electric guitars and that's a big part of the sound. By the time you can hear the subtle differences between various laminate guitars you'll know what you want. It could be more electric, more acoustic, brighter, darker, a 1.75" neck, bigger body, smaller body.. only way to know is to play. If a good sounding, good quality instrument with something other than 'Gibson' on the headstock fails to inspire you, then by all means. If you just want to learn jazz guitar on something hollow, there are more good choices now than there have ever been.

  8. #57

    User Info Menu

    those ibanez guitars sound nice but the gibson just blows them away. Most of the ibanez guitars have a compressed sound because the top doesn't vibrate as much.

    That's the way the aria herb ellis was as well although it had a sound post which was why in that case IMO...

  9. #58

    User Info Menu

    i had a 1953 175 that i had set up in nashville by the plek man - it was incredible

    as soon as i tried a sadowsky jim hall - i sold the 175 to get the jim hall

    (i've also had three other 175's of different eras before the 53 - and two es 150s)

    they sound very different indeed - that was why i went with the sadowsky

  10. #59

    User Info Menu

    FWIW, our own wonderful jazzer Dutchbopper has tried many guitars (see his blog), and has focused on the ES-175 and the Tal Farlow as his guitars of choice.

    I say focused, rather than settled for obvious reasons!

  11. #60

    User Info Menu

    I'm not aware of any 175 copies that are dimension and materials accurate - does such a thing exist? Normally the mahogany neck is replaced with maple for example.

  12. #61

    User Info Menu

    Every model of guitar has history...I wonder how many fameous players use a copy on gigs and during recordings...?

  13. #62

    User Info Menu

    I see that Epiphone have have re-released their ES 175. I have the older version which I upgraded, with Gibson, 57's Pup's, Vintage style tuners new pot, rewired etc. The new Epi 175 has similar Gibson Hardware, also I use Thomastik strings, Be-Bop. I also replaced the ceramic tone capaciter's with oil caps, which made the transition from treble to bass, and visa versa, much smoother. Epiphone guitars are generally well made and good value for the money, nice styling and great necks, but you have to replace the Pup's.

    I agree with you in that Epiphone with it's older hardware, Pup's etc. is not worth the effort, but the new release should have solved those issues. I am very pleased with the modifications and the sound is terrific. I have not played the new Epi but if it sounds anything like my modified version it should be pretty good for a jazz guitar under a $1000.
    Last edited by Blackwood-ca; 04-29-2015 at 03:56 PM.

  14. #63

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by goldenwave77
    ...but the 175 is a great "team player" in an ensemble. The 165 probably comes closest, for just a pure 175 jazz sound, and some would say they are indistinguishable. (The 175 can do more with its back pu.)
    I've tried four Gibson 175s over the past two years, three in the same store, same time: one from 1978, one of the first new Historic ones, and a new 2013 Custom Shop 175. Each was quite different within the definitional nuance of being "a 175", both tonally and in terms of feel. I also tried one other new Gibson CS in a different store; that one was also somewhat different and probably the best guitar I sampled. Anyway, I'm wondering if a 165 is really any more different than what I experienced between the four actual 175s.

    After all, besides that back pickup—which the large majority of jazz players rarely if ever use—what might possibly make the 165 not sound exactly like the 175? Can three extra holes and some mounted hardware in the top really make all that audible a difference? Is it possible to be able to reliably tell a 175 and a 165 apart in a blind listening test? Hmm...

  15. #64

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by ooglybong
    I've tried four Gibson 175s over the past two years, three in the same store, same time: one from 1978, one of the first new Historic ones, and a new 2013 Custom Shop 175. Each was quite different within the definitional nuance of being "a 175", both tonally and in terms of feel. I also tried one other new Gibson CS in a different store; that one was also somewhat different and probably the best guitar I sampled. Anyway, I'm wondering if a 165 is really any more different than what I experienced between the four actual 175s.

    After all, besides that back pickup—which the large majority of jazz players rarely if ever use—what might possibly make the 165 not sound exactly like the 175? Can three extra holes and some mounted hardware in the top really make all that audible a difference? Is it possible to be able to reliably tell a 175 and a 165 apart in a blind listening test? Hmm...
    I've played 2 165s. One i owned. It was an '89. My 175 is also an '89. They sound very similar. '89 is apparently a good year. The other 165 I played sound sounded very good and like a 175 also. I don't think there are many construction details that would make them any different. One odd thing on the 165 is that the string slots on the bridge were wider than the d'addario ball-ends so i had to insert a 1/2" length of wire through the hole in each ball end in order to keep the string ball end from slipping through the tailpiece opening. I was worried about the same issue with my '89 175 but it doesn't have that issue.

  16. #65
    Quote Originally Posted by jzucker
    The '80 has a maple neck and shaw pickups (which are really dark) and the combination of the maple neck and dark pickups didn't sound good to me...
    What pickups did Gibson put on the '89 175's ?

  17. #66
    I found this out. In '89 (and part of '88 and '90) Gibson used the Bill Lawrence circuit board pickup.
    Who Makes the Best ES-175 Clones?-lawrencehb-jpg

  18. #67

    User Info Menu

    A 165 with the mounted pickup does sound exactly like a 175. It is essentially a single pickup 175 with some slight cosmetic differences. The later 165 with the floater is a different animal altogether. Not my cup of tea at all...

  19. #68

    User Info Menu

    Epiphone guitars come very close or are just identical in sound en feel. They can can copy every Gibson guitar 'cause Gibson owns Epiphone. All other brand have to make bigger changes to they're guitars.

    A ES-175 type guitar basically is a 16" laminated maple guitar with mahogany neck and series humbucker(s). That is what makes the sound I think. Far bigger is the difference between who plays it!





    A-B comparison: Gibson ES-335 vs Epiphone ES-335pro. Close your eyes and tell the $ 2000,00 price difference.


  20. #69

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by jazzuki
    ...About two years ago I tried several Tokai FA 70( 175 copy) and found one that was the nearest to the Gibson 175- price £500 Gibson used circa 1975 £ 2500.No brainer for me. I think you can still get obtain the Tokai .Try it you may like it,
    FA245

    It is the Tokai FA245 now. The model designation changes with the price in JPY before sales tax: JPY245000. It was the FA235 a few years before so if you do a search be sure to punch in the right numbers.

    Who Makes the Best ES-175 Clones?-fa235l-jpg

    By Jove, I think Tokai got the TV-shape of the PAF pickup covers right whereas the Gibson Custom Shop can't.
    Last edited by Jabberwocky; 06-07-2015 at 09:57 AM.

  21. #70

    User Info Menu

    I love my Epi ES-175 Premium!

    For what it's worth, you might check this out this comparison:

  22. #71

    User Info Menu

    As previously noted, some, like the Eastmans, do not actually sound much like a 175. Who comes close sonically speaking? I have been looking at some Greco and Ibanez versions, so would appreciate any input on those.
    Please comment on cost, neck profiles, and any other key factors. I would prefer not to do a massive overhaul on hardware, but am willing to tinker a bit, so long as I do not have to drill new holes to replace cheap tuners.
    As always, thanks for the input!

  23. #72

    User Info Menu

    Epiphone ES-175 Premium is very good. Slimmer neck, but has a nice plummy tone. Also Matsumoku made 1970's copies (Aria Pro II, Greco, Westone, etc) are good but now pricey.


    Who Makes the Best ES-175 Clones?-epiphone-es-175-jpg

  24. #73

    User Info Menu

    I have a '73 Greco S50 that is very good. Excellent playability and the old Maxon pups sound perfect. Unfortunately the neck is skinnier than I would prefer.

    If you're looking at '70's Greco 175's (S or N 50, 55, 60), be aware that the neck shape on the older ones are smaller/skinnier that the later '70's ones. Also pay close attention to the fret edges. These had fret edge binding, and some of them -I assume the ones that have had fret levels- can end up with a weird detail where the fret ends INSIDE the binding, making the effective neck width less. Maybe this is common with guitars with fret edge binding, I don't know, but you can end up with a very skinny effective fret width if the binding edges weren't preserved.
    Who Makes the Best ES-175 Clones?-20170828_192743-jpg

  25. #74

    User Info Menu

    Lawsuit Aria Pro II EA650.


    Who Makes the Best ES-175 Clones?-1976-aria-pro-ii-ea650-jpg

    Last edited by cosmic gumbo; 08-30-2017 at 01:59 AM.

  26. #75

    User Info Menu

    A used Heritage 575 would do you real good.