Reply to Thread Bookmark Thread
Posts 1 to 24 of 24
  1. #1
    Hi everyone, I've arranged this beautiful Mingus tune for guitar, can you give me some advice or comment? Even about my playing.
    All information is in the video's description, thank you




    Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

  2.  

    The Jazz Guitar Chord Dictionary
     
  3. #2

    User Info Menu

    It's ok for my feelings,although you seem a little bit nervous when playing : You hit the strings rather loudly !
    I just don't understand a chord on bar 6,a little weird it seems
    Here is my version ;you'll notice i LOVE reverb!!



    cheers
    Emil

  4. #3
    Quote Originally Posted by emilP View Post
    It's ok for my feelings,although you seem a little bit nervous when playing : You hit the strings rather loudly !
    I just don't understand a chord on bar 6,a little weird it seems
    Here is my version ;you'll notice i LOVE reverb!!



    cheers
    Emil
    Thank you Goodbye pork pie hat the chord on 6's bar is a Fm7/11 and Fm7
    It's the harmonization of melody with the original chord.
    I leave a like on your YouTube video Goodbye pork pie hat you play so good, and I like your guitar!

    Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

  5. #4

    User Info Menu

    Enjoyed your chord melody solo of Goodbye Pork Pie Hat!

    That's a tune that I rarely hear anyone play as a solo guitar piece.

    Thanks for posting your rendition for us - very nice!

    Regards,
    Steven Herron
    Learn How To Arrange Chord Melody Solos

  6. #5

    User Info Menu

    A young musician who’s not afraid to play difficult tunes,congratulations !
    Hope you’ll send us others chord-melody tunes !
    Cheers
    Emil

  7. #6
    Quote Originally Posted by emilP View Post
    A young musician who’s not afraid to play difficult tunes,congratulations !
    Hope you’ll send us others chord-melody tunes !
    Cheers
    Emil
    Wow Goodbye pork pie hat thank you very very much Goodbye pork pie hat

    Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

  8. #7

    User Info Menu

    Davide, nice playing. I'll just ad that I rather like your hard attack. The actual string snapping is effective on this bluesy piece, and it sounds like you have control of it and know when it's appropriate. Dynamics are a good thing
    White belt
    My Youtube

  9. #8

    User Info Menu

    Great song, excellent choice. Good source of inspiration. I like your interpretation and the emphasis on the bass line as you approach the end and here your timing is fine.

    I like that you use dynamics as part of your expression. Consider amplification, recording gear and right hand sensitivity to modulate and control the dynamic expression.

    In general; when a change in finger setting takes a fraction of a second too long, the rhythm flow is interrupted. When playing solo you can modulate the tempo to maintain a rhythmic flow and you may consider rearranging those parts with priority to timing. (A single tone in time is often better than a chord off beat.). Your flow and timing is better in the second half of the arrangement.

    Keep it up, I look forward to hearing more arrangements from you.

  10. #9
    Quote Originally Posted by JCat View Post
    Great song, excellent choice. Good source of inspiration. I like your interpretation and the emphasis on the bass line as you approach the end and here your timing is fine.

    I like that you use dynamics as part of your expression. Consider amplification, recording gear and right hand sensitivity to modulate and control the dynamic expression.

    In general; when a change in finger setting takes a fraction of a second too long, the rhythm flow is interrupted. When playing solo you can modulate the tempo to maintain a rhythmic flow and you may consider rearranging those parts with priority to timing. (A single tone in time is often better than a chord off beat.). Your flow and timing is better in the second half of the arrangement.

    Keep it up, I look forward to hearing more arrangements from you.
    Thank you so much for your advice and for listening my video Goodbye pork pie hat. Yes, I still working on my hands to calibrate the touch of both hands.. and soon buy a guitar interface Goodbye pork pie hat
    Thank you so much at all for listening my video and give me advice Goodbye pork pie hat

    Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

  11. #10

    User Info Menu

    Very nice. I like your use of dynamics, which I think are too often ignored by many jazz guitarists. I only have two suggestions: 1) try playing it a bit more legato and 2) try soloing on the changes -- it's definitely one of the tougher tunes to solo on.

  12. #11

    User Info Menu

    OK..it is a complicated tune but one of Monks finest

    im posting this because its on of the best guitarist now or ever giving GBPPH a listen..but for guitar alone ..the Master..Jeff Beck...

    His blues playing is beyond most and his technique and control is a master class in real time..dont mean to hi jack thread but share a discovery ..hope all enjoy

    play well ...
    wolf

  13. #12

    User Info Menu

    jeff beck has always said, that he was turned on to the tune by john mclaughlins version of it

    here's john "duetting" with himself..opening track from his early lp- my goals beyond



    cheers

  14. #13

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by wolflen View Post
    OK..it is a complicated tune but one of Monks finest
    Not a Monk tune. Written by Charles Mingus.




  15. #14

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by Endorphins View Post
    Not a Monk tune. Written by Charles Mingus.



    yessss>>>>thanks,,,thinking of Round Midnight
    play well ...
    wolf

  16. #15

    User Info Menu

    To the OP - brave you for taking on what is a very ,beautiful , subtle and delicate tune . I would break down the sections and phrases and really work on articulating and interpreting them , rather like how I imagine a classical player might approach a piece . For me it feels like you are trying to get through it without a mistake rather than interpreting the piece. Its a great very subtle tune well worth exploring IMHO.

    While I have always been and still am a Beck fan - I find his version heavy handed to be honest.

    Will

  17. #16

    User Info Menu

    My favorite version is the Ralph Towner/Gary Burton duet on "Matchbook." Here's Towner playing solo.

  18. #17
    Quote Originally Posted by WillMbCdn5 View Post

    While I have always been and still am a Beck fan - I find his version heavy handed to be honest.

    Will
    Yes, I think the same thing. Jeff Beck is an extremely dynamic guitarist, I cry every time listen "Nessun Dorma" by Puccini playing from him. But I don't like so much his version of Good bye pork pie hat (it still however playing God-like, of course)

    Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

  19. #18

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by DaveRoberts View Post
    My favorite version is the Ralph Towner/Gary Burton duet on "Matchbook."
    Also on his album Anthem.

    Anthem (Ralph Towner album) - Wikipedia

  20. #19
    Quote Originally Posted by DaveRoberts View Post
    Very nice. I like your use of dynamics, which I think are too often ignored by many jazz guitarists. I only have two suggestions: 1) try playing it a bit more legato and 2) try soloing on the changes -- it's definitely one of the tougher tunes to solo on.
    I've rec a new video for this tune (recording well) with an improvvisation and some little change in playing, and in the bass part




    Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

  21. #20

    User Info Menu

    Good job on both your versions.

    Did you know that Mingus late in his life was a mentor of Joni Mitchell. Joni wrote lyrics to the song, ...

    B+
    Frank (aka fep)

  22. #21
    Quote Originally Posted by fep View Post
    Good job on both your versions.

    Did you know that Mingus late in his life was a mentor of Joni Mitchell. Joni wrote lyrics to the song, ...

    Thank you, yes I know Goodbye pork pie hat to interpretate this tune (but with every music I do it) I've listen much version and read a lot of information Goodbye pork pie hat

    Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

  23. #22

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by Davide _Ibanez View Post
    I've rec a new video for this tune (recording well) with an improvisation and some little change in playing, and in the bass part
    Very nice...I enjoyed your version and now have embarked on trying to learn this tune.

    As an aside in the new Jeff Beck documentary they display a letter from Mingus to Beck in which Mingus states he enjoyed Beck's interpretation of the tune. I think a photo of it is also in Beck's biography.

  24. #23

    User Info Menu

    Quote Originally Posted by alltunes View Post
    Very nice...I enjoyed your version and now have embarked on trying to learn this tune.

    As an aside in the new Jeff Beck documentary they display a letter from Mingus to Beck in which Mingus states he enjoyed Beck's interpretation of the tune. I think a photo of it is also in Beck's biography.
    Me too , well played by all
    i tried it a couple years ago and found it too difficult....
    gonna give it another go now ....

    thanks for for the inspiration guys !

  25. #24

    User Info Menu

    Good job by the OP.

    GBPH is a very hard tune for guitarists to play and improvise solo.

    This is my favorite guitar rendition of the tune from Tony McManus, a DADGAD, Celtic player: