Hi Ron,
I'm a mac user, not for garageband, for other reasons. I got Garageband as a bonus, though, but I've got a dell as well, and the main purpose for using garageband for me is the sequencer ability, to write lines for the other instruments and get extremely good, almost real sounding band. But for recording the guitar I use either Ableton live or Reaper. They are both better at least to my ears. Final mix I always do in Audacity, very neutral, and with limiting abilities to get a somewhat ok level. The ones you mention I'm sad to say I never tried. Both Reaper and Ableton are there for PC as well as Mac, you might try those if you haven't already.
Peace
Skei |