I have come to believe that ANY guitar made in a factory, (with some exceptions of course) is a crap shoot. I looked at a Dean Palomino Solo in a shop 2 weeks ago. It was like a factory second. The floating pick up was mounted at an angle on the neck so that the pick up was
bearing down on the top of the guitar. I pointed it out to the guitar guy who was also their tech and he removed the two front screws so that he could bring it up to a "floating" position. He had set the thing up previously, and the bridge was floating pretty high on the thumb screws to get the action he had on it. I played it, and it was a very muddy toned guitar. Sort of "waterlogged" sounding. I am sure many things could produce the problem, but for the 5 bills they wanted, I passed on it.
I have a Robelli Manhattan on it's way to me. I read Mr. Beaumont's review of one here, but also read several other reviews to the contrary on other sites. I have to wonder if the one he saw was a clunker like the Solo I saw. ( the Palomino was gorgeous too!, just dead sounding and flawed )
I think the Robelli I have on the way was made in the Peerless factory. I am hoping for the best. I owned 2 "American Standard" Strats; one an original 72 and the other an early 90s. Neither one of them played as well as a Chinese "Affinity" Strat (their bottom line guitar at the time) I paid 120 bucks for!!!
I know that when you get into the upscale guitar market you can probably expect better quality and QC, but with factory guitars I think it's the luck of the draw. I met a guy in Louisiana who had run one of Leo Fenders guitar factories. He didn't play guitar or even care about music, he had just held the job, so.... maybe my 72 had come from
his shop?
Glad your Palomino was a good'un!!!