I feel exactly the same way about Gibson necks, but Guild necks fit me perfectly. I have a late 90s X150 archtop (great US-made guitars still underpriced) and a mid 60s Starfire II they'll have to pry from my cold dead fingers. Both are 1 11/16ths" nut width but with a shallow "C" neck. Guild doesn't make electrics anymore but if you find a nice used one give it a try.
The X150s can still be found for 11-$1300. I swapped out the pickup for a Pete Biltoft blade but the standard pups are fine.
